Cat Litter Comparison Chart
Updated by Brandon F. on May 12, 2020
This is a full listing of all of the cat litters we have reviewed. This is the largest and most extensive list of cat litter reviews you will find anywhere on the internet but we are always adding to it. If you have any particular cat litters you would like us to review or have any comments about current reviews or specifications please contact us!
| Product | Our Rating | Cost (in $/pound) on Amazon | Ingredients | Clumping Ability | Our Full Review | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | America Litter | 4.5 Stars | $$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | America Litter Ultra Scooping | 4 Stars | $$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Naturals | 4 Stars | $$$ | Wood, minerals, plants, and baking soda | Yes | Link |
 | Arm & Hammer Clump and Seal with MicroGuard | 4.5 Stars | $$$ | Clay and Baking Soda | Yes | Link |
 | Arm & Hammer Super Scoop Fresh Scent | 4 Stars | $ | Clay and baking soda crystals | Yes | Link |
 | Arm & Hammer Multi-Cat Unscented | 3.5 Stars | $ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Arm & Hammer Essentials Double Duty Natural | 3 Stars | $$$$$ | Corn fiber and baking soda | Yes | Link |
 | Arm & Hammer Double Duty Clumping | 3 Stars | $ | Clay and baking soda crystals | Yes | Link |
 | Arm & Hammer Essentials Natural Clumping | 3 Stars | $ | Corn fiber | Yes | Link |
 | Arm & Hammer Ultra Last | 3 Stars | $$$$ | Clay and baking soda | Yes | Link |
 | Arm & Hammer Essentials Multi-Cat Natural | 2.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Corn fiber, baking soda, and plant extract | Yes | Link |
 | Arm & Hammer Multi-Cat Extra Strength | 2.5 Stars | $$ | Clay and baking soda | Yes | Link |
 | Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Lightweight Fresh Scent | 2 Stars | $$$ | Clay and baking soda | Yes | Link |
 | Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Lightweight Multi-Cat | 2 Stars | $$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Arm & Hammer Platinum Double Duty | 4.5 Stars | $ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Arm & Hammer Super Scoop Fragrance-Free | 2 Stars | $ | Clay and baking soda | Yes | Link |
 | Boxiecat | 4.5 Stars | $$-$$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Blue Buffalo Naturally Fresh Ultra Odor Control | 3.5 Stars | $$$ | Walnut shells | Yes | Link |
 | CatSpot | 3.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Coconut | No | Link |
 | Cat’s Pride Fresh & Light Quick Action | 5 Stars | $$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Cat’s Pride Fresh & Light Ultimate Care Premium Unscented Hypoallergenic Multi-Cat | 4.5 Stars | $$$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Cat’s Pride Fresh & Light Ultimate Premium Scented Multi-Cat | 4 Stars | $$$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Cat’s Pride Fresh & Light Fragrance-Free | 4 Stars | $$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Cat’s Pride Fresh & Clean | 4 Stars | $ | Clay | No | Link |
 | Cat’s Pride Scoopable Scented | 3 Stars | $$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Cat’s Pride Complete Multi-Cat Scoopable | 3 Stars | $$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Cat’s Pride Natural Scoopable | 3 Stars | $ | Clay and fruit/vegetable extract | Yes | Link |
 | Cat’s Pride Complete Multi-Cat | 3 Stars | $ | Clay | No | Link |
 | Cat’s Pride Fresh & Light All Day Odor Control | 2.5 Stars | $$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Cat’s Pride Lightweight Scoopable Unscented | 3.5 Stars | $$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Cat’s Pride Natural | 2.5 Stars | $$$ | Clay | No | Link |
 | Cat's Pride Scoopable Unscented | 3.5 Stars | $$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Cedarific | 4 Stars | $$$$ | Wood | No | Link |
 | Ever Clean Extra Strength Unscented | 4 Stars | $ | Clay and natural minerals | Yes | Link |
 | Ever Clean EverFresh | 4 Stars | $$$$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Ever Clean Extra Strength Scented | 3.5 Stars | $$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Ever Clean Multiple Cat | 3 Stars | $$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Feline Pine Non-Clumping | 3 Stars | $ | Pine | No | Link |
 | Feline Pine Clumping | 3 Stars | $ | Pine | Yes | Link |
 | Fresh Step Clean Paws Multi-Cat | 4 Stars | $$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Fresh Step Clean Paws Triple Action | 4 Stars | $$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Fresh Step Crystals | 2.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Crystal | No | Link |
 | Fresh Step Extreme Clay | 2.5 Stars | $$$ | Clay | No | Link |
 | Fresh Step Extreme Lightweight Scented | 1.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Fresh Step Extreme Mountain Spring Scent | 4 Stars | $$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Fresh Step Extreme Odor Control Scented | 1.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Fresh Step Extreme Odor Control Unscented | 3.5 Stars | $$$$ | Clay and antimicrobial agents | Yes | Link |
 | Fresh Step Fast Acting Scoopable | 2.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Clay and plant extract | Yes | Link |
 | Fresh Step Lasting Power Scoopable | 3 Stars | $$$$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Fresh Step Multi-Cat Unscented Scoopable | 3 Stars | $$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Fresh Step Mutli-Cat Scented Scoopable | 2.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Clay, activated carbon, and plant extract | Yes | Link |
 | Fresh Step Odor Shield Scented | 3 Stars | $$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Fresh Step Odor Shield Unscented | 2 Stars | $$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Fresh Step Plus Dual Action Crystals | 2.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Crystal and clay | Yes | Link |
 | Fresh Step Triple Action | 2.5 Stars | $$$ | Clay, carbon, and plant extract | Yes | Link |
 | Garfield Flushable Tiny Grains | 4 Stars | $$$$ | Plant-based sand | Yes | Link |
 | Garfield Flushable Grand | 4 Stars | $$$$ | Plant-based sand | Yes | Link |
 | Healthy Pet ökocat Pine | 4 Stars | $ | Pine pellet | No | Link |
 | Healthy Pet ökocat Soft Step Clumping | 3 Stars | $$$$$ | Wood granules | Yes | Link |
 | Healthy Pet ökocat Natural Paper Dust Free | 2.5 Stars | $$$$ | Paper | Yes | Link |
 | Healthy Pet ökocat Natural Wood Clumping | 2 Stars | $$$$$ | Wood | Yes | Link |
 | Healthy Pet ökocat Natural Wood Clumping for Long Hair Breeds | 2 Stars | $$ | Wood pellet | Yes | Link |
 | Jonny Cat Complete | 4 Stars | $ | Clay | No | Link |
 | Jonny Cat Fragrance Free | 3 Stars | $$$$$ | Clay and fruit/vegetable extract | No | Link |
 | Jonny Cat Original | 2.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Clay | No | Link |
 | LitterMaid Premium Natural Clumping | 2.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Clay and corn | Yes | Link |
 | Nature’s Miracle Intense Defense Fragrance Free Clumping | 4 Stars | $$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Nature’s Miracle Intense Defense Clumping | 4 Stars | $ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Nature’s Miracle Multi-Cat Clumping | 3 Stars | $ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Nature’s Miracle Just for Cats Easy Care Crystal | 2.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Crystals | No | Link |
 | Nature’s Miracle Just for Cats Natural Pine | 1.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Pine granules | Yes | Link |
 | Perfect Litter | 2 Stars | $$$$$ | Vermiculite, perlite, guar gum, and proprietary materials | Yes | Link |
 | PetSafe ScoopFree Crystal Cat Litter | 3.5 Stars | $$$$ | Silica Gel | No | Link |
 | Precious Cat Cat Attract | 4.5 Stars | $ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Precious Cat Classic | 3 Stars | $$$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Precious Cat Kitten Attract | 3 Stars | $$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Precious Cat Long Haired | 2.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Silica gel and herbs | No | Link |
 | Precious Cat R&R Respiratory Relief Clumping Clay | 4 Stars | $ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Precious Cat R&R Respiratory Relief Silica Gel | 2.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Silica gel | No | Link |
 | Precious Cat Senior | 2 Stars | $$$$$ | Silica gel | No | Link |
 | Precious Cat Touch of Outdoors | 2 Stars | $$$ | Grass | Yes | Link |
 | Precious Cat Ultra | 4.5 Stars | $ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Precious Cat Ultra Scented | 3.5 Stars | $$$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Premium Choice All Natural Unscented | 3.5 Stars | $ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Premium Choice Dual Strength | 3 Stars | $ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Premium Choice Extra Strength with Baking Soda | 2.5 Stars | $ | Clay and baking soda | Yes | Link |
 | Premium Choice Multi-cat | 2.5 Stars | $ | Clay and baking soda | Yes | Link |
 | Pretty Litter | 4 Stars | $$$$$ | Silica gel | No | Link |
 | ProSense Fresh Results Clumping | 3 Stars | $$$$ | Corn | Yes | Link |
 | ProSense Fresh Results Crystal | 3.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Silica Gel | No | Link |
 | Scoop Away Super Clump Scented | 3.5 Stars | $$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Scoop Away Extra Strength | 3 Stars | $$$$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Scoop Away Multi-Cat Plus Crystals | 3 Stars | $$ | Clay and crystals | Yes | Link |
 | Scoop Away Multi-Cat Scented | 2.5 Stars | $$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Scoop Away Super Clump Unscented | 2.5 Stars | $$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Scoop Away Complete Performance | 2 Stars | $$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | So Phresh Odor Control Paper Pellet | 3 Stars | $$$$ | Paper pellets | No | Link |
 | So Phresh Advanced Odor Control Unscented | 3 Stars | $$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | So Phresh Odor-Lock Crystal | 2.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Silica Gel | No | Link |
 | So Phresh Dual Odor Guard | 2.5 Stars | $$$$ | Mineral crystals | Yes | Link |
 | So Phresh Advanced Odor Control Scented | 2 Stars | $$$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Swheat Scoop Multi-Cat | 2.5 Stars | $$$ | Wheat | Yes | Link |
 | Swheat Scoop Original | 2 Stars | $$ | Wheat | Yes | Link |
 | Tidy Cats 24/7 Performance | 4.5 Stars | $$$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Tidy Cats Small Spaces | 4.5 Stars | $ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Tidy Cats Instant Action Non-Clumping | 3.5 Stars | $ | Clay | No | Link |
 | Tidy Cats 4 in 1 Strength | 3 Stars | $$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Tidy Cats 24/7 Performance Non-Clumping | 3 Stars | $ | Clay | No | Link |
 | Tidy Cats Glade Tough Odor Solutions Non-Clumping | 3 Stars | $ | Clay | No | Link |
 | Tidy Cats Lightweight 24/7 Performance | 2.5 Stars | $$$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Tidy Cats Glade Tough Odor Solutions | 2.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Tidy Cats Instant Action | 2.5 Stars | $$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Tidy Cats Yesterday’s News Original | 2.5 Stars | $$$$ | Recycled paper | No | Link |
 | Tidy Cats Lightweight with Glad Tough Odor Solutions | 2 Stars | $$$$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Tidy Cats Lightweight Instant Action | 2 Stars | $$$$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Tidy Cats Dual Power | 2 Stars | $ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | Tidy Cats Pure Nature | 2 Stars | $$$ | Cedar, corn, and pine | Yes | Link |
 | UltraPet Crystal Clear Litter Pearls | 3.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Silica gel | No | Link |
 | UltraPet Ultra Pearls | 3 Stars | $$$$$ | Silica gel | No | Link |
 | UltraPet Ultra Micro Crystals | 3 Stars | $$$$$ | Silica gel | No | Link |
 | UltraPet Litter Pearls Micro Crystals | 3 Stars | $$$$$ | Silica gel | No | Link |
 | UltraPet Trackless Litter Pearls | 2.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Silica gel | No | Link |
 | UltraPet Better Way Original | 2.5 Stars | $ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | UltraPet Better Way Fresh | 2.5 Stars | $$$ | Clay | Yes | Link |
 | UltraPet Ultra Lite | 2.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Clay and silica gel | Yes | Link |
 | UltraPet Better Way Flushable | 1.5 Stars | $$$$ | Zeolite | Yes | Link |
 | UltraPet Better Way Cedar | 1.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Bentonite and cedar | Yes | Link |
 | Weruva | 3.5 Stars | $$$$$ | Japanese Hinoki Wood and Green Tea | Yes | Link |
 | World’s Best Cat Litter Lavender Scented Multiple Cat Clumping | 4 Stars | $$$ | Wood grains, corn kernel, and lavender oil | Yes | Link |
 | World’s Best Cat Litter Multiple Cat Clumping | 4 Stars | $$ | Wood fibers and corn kernels | Yes | Link |
 | World’s Best Cat Litter Forest Scented Clumping | 3 Stars | $$$$$ | Corn kernels and wood fibers | Yes | Link |
 | World’s Best Cat Litter Clumping | 3 Stars | $$$$$ | Wood fiber and corn kernels | Yes | Link |
 | World’s Best Cat Litter Advanced Naturals Scented Pine Blend Multi Cat | 2 Stars | $$$$ | Pine | Yes | Link |
 | World’s Best Cat Litter Advanced Natural Original | 1.5 Stars | $$$$ | Corn, plant fibers, and wood | Yes | Link |